Sunday, September 22, 2013

As the minor league baseball season comes to a close it is time to re-rank the prospects within the Giants minor league system. Here is the link to mlb.com's top 20 Giants' prospects: http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/prospects/watch/y2013/ .
Just a few points of interest: first, in my view, I rank ceiling above "MLB readiness." Second, this list is to encourage debate, not stifle it; I encourage any all all comments.

1) Kyle Crick - Cieling of a future ace, plus fastball and slider 12.45 K/9 rate
2) Clayton Blackburn - Above average fastabll, plus control, WHIP of 1.10, 9.34 K/9
3) Chris Stratton - Plus fastball and slider, great pedigree, 8.39 K/9, 1.33 WHIP, integral part of the Giants        future
4) Joe Panik - .257/.333/.347 slash line, excellent bat control, prototypical number two hitter
5) Martin Agosta - Polished, 10.70 K/9, 1.09 WHIP, plus fastball and changeup, part of a talented core of       pitchers in the lower minor leagues
6) Mike Kickham - Above average fastball, got his feet wet in the majors this year, one of the few advanced      pitching prospects in the Giants' system, may be a better fit in a relief role
7) Heath Hembree - Future closer, plus fastball with a lot of life, struggled with his command, 10.25 K/9
8) Christian Arroyo - Plus hit tool, average power, excellent leadership and work ethic, MVP of the Arizona      League, above average plate discpline, .326/.388/.511 slash line
9) Andrew Susac - .252/.359/.454 slash line, 12 homeruns, plus power, needs to refine his hit tool and cut        down on strikeouts
10) Gustavo Cabrera - .247/.379/.360 slash line in his first year of professional baseball, plus power, plus            speed, comporable to Justin Upton and Byron Buxton at the same age
11) Edwin Escobar - Above average fastball and changeup, 1.14 K/9, 1.10 WHIP, could have an outside          shot at a rotation spot after doing well at Double - A Richmond
12) Mac Williamson - Plus power from the right side, advanced hitter but needs to refine his hit tool,                   .292/.375/.504 slash line, 25 homeruns, .212 ISO
13) Aldaberto Mejia - Above average fastball and plus control, 9.21 K/9, 1.13 WHIP, another member of          a very promising group of young arms
14) Ryder Jones - Second round draft choice, above average hit and power tools, .317/.394/.400 slash line,       great arm at thrid base, impressed Ryan Vogelsong with his at bats when Vogelsong went on a rehab             assignment
15) Eric Surkamp - First year back from Tommy John, above average fastball and curveball, 2.80 ERA and        a WHIP of 1.00 across two levels this year, someone to watch compete for a rotation spot come spring        training
16) Brian Ragira - Advanced bat out of Stanford, plus hit tool with above average power, needs to cut               down on the strikeouts, could advance quickly if he makes adjustments
17) Gary Brown - Plus athlete, excellent make up, plus-plus speed, destroys left-handed pitching, once a              considered a cornerstone now his future is in question
18) Francisco Paguero - Good athlete with injury history, above average power and hit tool, also has an              incredible arm that profiles well in rightfield
19) Ty Blach - Features an above average fastball and curveball, ERA of 2.90, WHIP of 1.09
20) Daniel Slania - Fifth round pick out of Notre Dame, closer make up, 9.22 K/9, 1.98 BB/9, 1.17 WHIP

Here they are, the future of the San Francisco Giants. The strength of the Giants' system is pitching at the lower levels of the system. Most of pitchers will, next year, begin their ascent to advanced competition as they head up to double and triple - A. The glaring weakness of the Giants system is the hitting. They lack few advanced bats, as well as raw, unrefined hitters; even those who are "advanced" have struggled this year and last in Panik, Brown, and Paguero.

In terms of pitching, keep an eye on the next wave of arms coming up through the system in Crick, Blackburn, Stratton, and Agosta.

In terms of bats, look for Panik to make some adjustments coming into spring training, as he is one of the few advanced, major league ready hitters the Giants have. I am excited about Susac who really made strides this year before getting hurt; if he can cut down on the strikeouts moving forward he will create an interesting dynamic behind home plate. The same idea applies to Mac Williamson, who, if he can cut down on the strikeouts, can be an effective major league hitter. Young hitters like Gustavo Cabrera and Christian Arroyo are flashing impressive skills, but are still a few seasons away and need to refine their overall game.

Stats courtesy of mlb.com, milb.com, and fangraphs.com

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Higher Expectations

Last week we focused on the future Giants who enjoyed breakout seasons: Kyle Crick, Clayton Blackburn, Martin Agosta and Mac Williamson. In this week's post I will examine farmhands who posted lackluster numbers and didn't quite live up to expectations: Joe Panik, Gary Brown, and Heath Hembree. These three Giants have received a serious amount of acclaim since being drafted, largely because of their success at the lower levels, but enjoyed less success this year than what was expected.

Joe Panik was the first round draft choice of the Giants in the 2011 draft (29 overall) out of St. John's University. Enjoying a great amount of success in his first professional season: being named the MVP of the Northwest League, to the Arizona Fall League Rising Stars game, and an organizational all star. In 2012 he played a full season at high-A San Jose, and although he struggled the first half, finished strong posting a .297 batting average, and walking more times than he struck out (58 vs. 54, respectively). Panik did struggle this year at double-A Richmond with his batting average dipping to .257 - although posting a similar strikeout-to-walk ratio. Panik's defense at short or second has never been stellar, but given the Giants uncertain second base situation, compared to their solidified short stop situation, it was assumed that Panik would slide into the second base slot. Many Giants fans hoped that, given Marco Scutaro's ailing defense, Panik would be ready sooner rather than later. Given that the jump from single-A to double-A is one of the most challenging jumps a prospect will face, and that Richmond is largely a pitcher's park, it is understandable that Panik struggled this year, but a bit disconcerting that he may not be the prospect that Giants's fans hoped he would be. What does bode well for Panik is that he has a solid approach, consistently walking more than he strikes out and consistently putting the ball in play. If Panik can make some adjustments going into spring training he could break with the big league club, but if not, he may need another year at triple-A.

Gary Brown was the first round pick by the Giants in 2010 where he, like Panik, enjoyed considerable success early on. Best know for his speed-hit combination, he was lauded as the center fielder of the future for the Giants. In his first full season at high-A San Jose, Brown his .336 with 14 home runs and 53 stolen bases and showered with accolades (futures game selection, California League Rookie of the Year, Cal League post season all star, Baseball America minor league all star, and MLB.com Class A Advanced hitter of the year). Brown's success tapered off a bit in 2012 at double-A when he hit .279 with 33 stolen bases and an OBP of .347. This year Brown struggled the most, posting a .231 average, 17 stolen bases and an OBP of .286. Brown has dealt with lofty expectations since he was drafted and he has handled these expectations with poise because of his off the charts character and work ethic. He was lauded, coming out of college as one of the best athletes - albeit very raw athletes - available in the 2010 draft, and consistently earns high marks for his athleticism and defense within the Giants organization; but his bat is the concern. Never one to draw high walk totals (46 in 2011 was his highest), his OBP relies heavily on how much contact he makes which is generally not an ideal trait in a prototypical lead off hitter. His strike-out totals are often too high but they are erratic as well, ranging anywhere from 12-22%, which points to an adjustment in approach. Given that Brown's speed is his greatest, and most valuable asset, he has never been efficient on the base paths, getting thrown out 36%, 55%, and 65% of his attempts in 2011, 2012, and 2013, respectively. His unorthodox setup at the plate also hinders him against right handed pitchers because of the way he sets and loads his hands. His age makes it difficult from him to continue to develop, considering also that he has already played a full season of triple-A; Angel Pagan's success at the top of the lineup on the 2012 championship team also complicates matters. I am a fan of Gary Brown and would like to see him succeed with the Giants, however, I do not see him contributing to the big league team in a substantial manner.

Heath Hembree has been hailed as the successor to the closer role in San Francisco. When Brian Wilson went down, fans clamored for his promotion. However Sergio Romo has inherited the closer role and enjoyed more ninth inning success than many fans projected and given Hembree more, much needed, development time. Hembree touts a mid to high 90's fastball and a slider that can be plus with more refinement. His huge season in 2011 really put him on the radar of Giants fans and the front office when he notched 38 saves across two levels. He has struggled in Fresno letting his ERA balloon to 4.07, while maintaining 10.25 K/9 rate and a 3.94 BB/9 rate. Through dealing with injuries he did deal with a dip in velocity and an increase in his walks. Scouts have been impressed with his stint in the big leagues so far (3 IP, 2 BB's, and 3 K's) because he has focused primarily on throwing strikes instead of trying to blow fastballs by major league hitters. Brian Sabean does believe in the development and maturation of future closers from within the system. Hembree should receive sporadic innings depending on game situations throughout the rest of this season. Although his performance this year has been less than stellar, he remains a future closer option down the road. By refining his command and his slider in the off season he is still poised to break with the club and earn regular innings next year.

Facts and statistics courtesy of mlb.com, milb.com and fangraphs.com

Sunday, September 8, 2013

Prospect Summary - Breakout Seasons

At this point in the year the minor league baseball season has ended for most teams and players. In the next few posts I will analyze breakout seasons, surprises, disappointments, and so on.

This post is dedicated to the Giants prospects who had breakout years: Kyle Crick, Clayton Blackburn, Martin Agosta, and Mac Williamson.

Kyle Crick is one of the most well known prospects in the entire Giants' minor league system. This year Crick established himself as one of the most promising prospect in all of baseball and set a number of career bests. After an initial oblique strain, he rebounded with increased velocity and strikeouts. This year at single - A advanced San Jose, Crick posted a career - high 12.45 k/9 percentage, career - low 5.11 BB/9 rate, and stranding a career - best 78.5% of base runners.
        What to keep an eye on: While no one is questioning Crick's pure stuff, he will need to refine his command. Some scouts don't think he will ever have better than average command, but his motion will allow him to improve. Other scouts believe that if he isn't able to refine his command he has a closer ceiling, either way he can contribute on the major league level. The Orioles scout I spoke to a few months ago wants to see him come into camp next year in better shape and with a better "feel" for his pitches.  
     What to be excited about: Crick's dominating, ace - like, stuff was showcases consistently. He has the body of a future innings eater in the mold of Matt Cain.

Clayton Blackburn is a lesser - known prospect, but one fans should be equally excited about. Blackburn finished with 133.0 innings this year at single - A advanced, San Jose. He also had 9.34 k/9, 2.37 BB/9, and an impressive 1.10 WHIP. Blackburn's strikeout rate was impressive this year because he doesn't profile as a future strikeout leader, and he was able to keep with walks down. He features a plus fastball and is above average with his command, curve and change. He sits comfortably in the low - 90's but has the ability to reach back for a few extra "ticks" if need be. His motion is a bit unorthodox, but educes a good about of ground balls and strikeouts.
     What to keep an eye on: With his profile, it will be important that he continues to refine his command and off speed pitches, as well as his conditioning, according to my Orioles source.
     What to be excited about: Blackburn is a durable starter that has the ability to be a future number two started alongside Crick down the road. With his solid four-pitch mix he should continue to develop at double - A Richmond next year.

Martin Agosta was the second round pick by the Giants in 2012 out of St. Mary's College, in Moraga California. Surprisingly, Agosta was left in full season A ball this year in Agusta, but nevertheless he put up stunning numbers this year: 2.06 ERA, 91.2 innings pitched, 109 k's, 43 BB, and a WHIP of 1.09. It's assumed that although he is considered an "advanced" prospect because of his time in college, he was left at low - A because the Giants wanted him to develop his change up that has the potential to be a plus pitch. This is in addition to his future plus fastball and his above - average slider and control.
      What to keep an eye on: Look to see if the Giants allow Agosta to skip San Jose because of his experience and success in Agusta, and allow him to go right to double - A Richmond. He should continue to develop his change up, which the Giants are clearly impressed with, and his fastball command.
     What to be excited about: Blackburn and Agosta share a similar mold, so Agosta looks to feature in an impressive top of the rotation with Crick, Blackburn, and Agosta.

Mac Williamson was the third - round pick in 2012 out of Wake Forest. He had an impressive debut last year making it all the way to low - A Agusta in his first year and posted impressive power numbers. Neither Baseball America nor MLB.com has Williamson ranked as a "top prospect," but he is someone both the Giants and I are very hopeful for. Williamson's power is legit, and he has as much as anyone else in the Giants system, grading out easily as plus. His hit tool is a little father behind grading out as above average, but can improve if he makes the requisite adjustments. His numbers this year are impressive: 25 HR, .292 AVG, .375 OBP, and an .879 OPS. His adjustments are imperative, however. The Giants have very few, if any, advanced hitting prospects that could make a big league impact in the near future. As I mentioned above, his power is legit, but he needs to tap into it more. A scout I spoke to referred to him as a "collision hitter," one who is all - or - nothing at the plate, which is corroborated by his high strike - out totals and "great" ISO (isolated power rating that measures how may extra base hits a player has).
     What to keep an eye on: Can Williamson make the necessary adjustments in his approach to tap into his power, and thus, contribute to the Giants as a middle - of - the - order force, not as a fourth outfielder.
     What to be excited about: Be very excited about his power and his ability to make adjustments. If he does so, he could be making a big league impact by the end of next season.

All statistics and advanced metrics were taken from fangraphs.com

Sunday, September 1, 2013

Weekly Prospect Round-Up

Hi all, I apologize for the delay in posts. I have left for college and busy with everything you can possibly imagine. Unfortunately, I no longer have the privilege of watching the Giants play every night, as I am on the other side of the country; therefore my content stands to change a bit. I can no longer offer my perspective of the Giants on a daily basis, it simply wouldn't be fair to post conjecture based upon what I see on twitter each night.

From this point forward most of my content will be about minor league baseball prospects around the game. Although it is equally difficult, if not more, to evaluate minor leaguers without a first - hand perspective, I will do my best to report weekly round-ups of prospects and where they might fit into the Giants long - term plans. 

This week I would like to highlight and congratulate first round pick (25th overall) Christian Arroyo. Arroyo was named the Arizona League MVP this week. He boasts a slash line of .326/.388/.511, five triples, two homeruns, 18 doubles, and 39 runs batted in in 45 games this year at the shortstop position. His K rate has also been impressive: his 17% strikeout rate grades out at "above average" according to FanGraphs. This is one of my favorite aspects of Arroyo's game. At a time when strikeout rates are skyrocketing, and no one seems to care, Arroyo has the ability to hit the ball hard, put it in play, thus putting the pressure on the defense and he is reaping the rewards. MLB.com's Jonathon Mayo grades Arroyo as "plus" with his hit, arm, and field tools. In addition to his plus tools Arroyo is also praised for his off the charts instincts and baseball IQ.

His ability to play shortstop has also been commendable. When he was drafted experts weren't sure he could stick at short. They said he didn't have the range for short, the quickness for second or the bat for third; some even said he would be best suited at catcher. To Arroyo's credit he has played short, and played it well, since the very first day he was a Giant.

Over his Arroyo's last ten games he is batting .432 with one homerun, seven runs batted in and an on-base percentage of .475.

Where Arroyo fits into the long - term plans of the Giants remains to be seen. Arroyo is playing rookie ball still and there is no guarantee that he will make the jump to San Jose next year either. Considering that he may be sent to Agusta instead, he is still anywhere from two - four years away from a major league debut.

For the sake of argument lets say Arroyo would be knocking on the San Francisco Giants' door in the near future. Brandon Crawford has shown that he is capable of being a major leaguer, maybe even an all - star next year; therefore I cannot imagine a scenario in which Crawford is not locked up by the Giants. Marco Scutaro is not going to be able to handle the rigors of an everyday second basemen much longer with his ailing health so second base is an option. Joe Panik is having a lackluster year at AA leading people to question whether he can be an effective major leaguer - scout Keith Law says his cieling is as a "utility guy." Third base is also a question mark with Pablo Sandoval's future uncertain. He will come into camp this year motivated and in shape, but he has opened the door for people to question both long term. I think the most likely scenario is that Arroyo makes his impact with the Giants at second base - not to say he isn't fit to play short, more so because second base will allow him a direct and expedited path to the majors.

Congratulations again to Christian Arroyo and please continue to follow and spread the word about A Giant Family. 

Monday, August 5, 2013

Weekly Prospect Round-Up

Kyle Crick, the top prospect in the Giants system, had another dominating start at high – A San Jose. Crick went five innings, allowing four hits, two runs, two walks and eleven strikeouts. Crick’s biggest issue thus far has been his lack of control, consistently issuing three to five walks which is far too many considering he usually doesn't pitch more than six innings – so it is encouraging to see him cut down on the walks. With his most recent performance he lowered his season’s WHIP to 1.34 and his ERA to 1.58. It’s clear at this point that Crick’s plus-plus fastball and plus slider are dominating California League hitters, in a hitter-friendly league, but his command and developing curveball and changeup will determine how long he spends in the minor leagues. The development of a change up is a staple of the Giants’ farm system so it’s safe to assume that Crick will continue to refine his changeup and curveball until the Giants are convinced his off-speed pitches can be effective against major league hitters. It is exciting to know that the Giants have another frontline starter working his way through the minor leagues.

Adalberto Mejia is a lesser known prospect within the Giants’ system; ranked number 19 according to mlb.com and number 10 according to Baseball America. He touts slightly above average pitches in his fastball, curveball, and change up, with his command grading out as plus. His left-handed delivery is clean and repeatable and he uses his sinking fastball and changeup to induce both ground balls and fly balls because of his efficient knee high command. His velocity consistently sits between 89-91, peaking at 93, but that could rise as he continues to grow into his 6-3 frame. Mejia doesn’t have the ace ceiling that Crick has, but he is expected to be an effective number three starter in the Giant future rotation. His most recent start at high – A this week was equally as effective as Crick’s, going six innings, allowing six hits, one walk, one earned run and seven strikeouts.

The Giants were criticized after this year’s draft because they took multiple high school bats at slots that were considered well above what they were capable of. Not only were these players, Christian Arroyo and Ryder Jones, taken above their predicted slots, Arroyo and Jones didn't have clearly defined roles. Thus far, both Arroyo and Jones have played well enough to quiet some of their detractors.


Ryder Jones was not someone who I was particularly enthused with when I heard the Giants call his name. He was the first Stanford recruit to be signed away from his commitment in nearly ten years. At a corner position, his hit and power tools grade out as above average, but those will most likely fluctuate as he continues to grow and develop. He hasn't flashed much power yet, with only one home run in 84 at bats, but he is hitting .357 with a .444 on base percentage. His lefty-righty splits are similar and although he is striking out a bit too much (about 22% of the time) he is displaying an approach at the plate and he isn't simply just flailing at everything that comes his way. At this moment, he is a player in the mold of Nick Castellanos of the Tigers, and Jones’ bat is giving Giants fans something to be excited about. 

Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Trade Deadline Part Three

As the trade deadline rapidly approaches the possibility that the Giants actually make a significant move is dwindling away.

The following trade proposals deal with two players: Sergio Romo, and Hunter Pence. Both players are unlikely to be dealt but they are loads of fun to speculate about.

Sergio Romo has been more than anyone had ever expected. Sergio was drafted out of Mesa State College by the Giants in the 28th round of the 2005 amateur draft. Initially the reciprocal of Javier Lopez, he has improved each year as a Giant developing a wipe-out, no-dot slider that is lethal to both lefties and righties. With the development of a change-up he has established himself as a reliable closer who is cut from a different cloth. He doesn't over power hitters with the traditional 99 mile per hour fastball, but he methodically strikes batters out and racks up saves up pinpoint location and movement. He has also done well to dispel the stigma that he can't be reliable because of his injury history and has remained healthy this year.

I would venture to say that Romo's draft stock has never been higher coming off three consecutively effective years, a World Series championship, and significant rest this year.  One closer has already been traded thus far, Jose Veras, from the Astros to the White Sox. In return, the Astros received Danry Vasquez, an outfielder with a "plus" hit tool and average power.

I think this late in the game it is unlikely that Romo is traded, especially with Heath Hembree struggling to keep base runners off the base paths. The fun part is in speculating where Romo could land. The Tigers, Rockies, Orioles, and Indians have all expressed a need for closers. Especially with Glenn Perkins of the Twins being cost-prohibitive for most teams, Romo could be a fit. An intra-division trade with the Rockies would be unlikely, but the Giants could ask for Eddie Butler, a high ceiling starter with a plus fastball. Other than that, the Rockies don't have big league ready starting pitching, which is what the Giants need.

The Orioles have Kevin Gausman in triple - A, but he is probably as close to untouchable as any prospect can be. An alternative would be Eduardo Rodriguez who is currently in double - A and under performing but boasts a plus slider and fastball. Never doubt the development of a pitcher the Giants get their hands on.

The Indians are most likely out at this point with their acquisition of Marc Rzepcznski and their lack of anything resembling major league ready pitching.

That leaves the Tigers who are also unlikely with their aforementioned moves and their lack of pitching depth. Romo will most likely stay.

Hunter Pence is fun to speculate about. He has been very forthcoming with his adulation for San Francisco and he has permanently endeared himself to this fan base with his "preaching" antics that led the Giants to a World Series title.

Although he had 100 RBI for the Giants last year, his batting average and home run totals were lackluster. This year has been better after he practically carried the Giants early in the year with a .330 batting average, five home runs, and 15 RBI in May alone. He has tapered off from there but has still been solid.

It would be difficult to command a Zach Wheeler - esque player like the Giants gave up when they acquired Carlos Beltran, but they could still ask for a high level prospect.

If the Giants were to deal Pence, though, than what does that say about next year? The Giants would be creating another hole in the outfield that they cannot fill in addition to all of their other question marks. In addition to that, the compensatory picks and qualifying offers come into play as Pence approaches free agency and will look for a raise from his $13.8 million salary, likely $15 million rage, that would put him in the B.J. Upton range and most people know how that has worked out.

If the Giants offer Pence a qualifying offer he will except, and he will want to return; the offer cannot be disingenuous. Would he resign with the Giants after being dealt if they explicitly stated they wanted him back? Only he knows, I would say it would be difficult to say the least and pricey to state the obvious. However, it would be tremendously valuable to the Giants if he would.

The Angles, Red Sox, Pirates, Cardinals, and Tigers are interesting. The Angles have a major league ready first basemen in C.J. Cron with a plus bat across the board, but it would be difficult to move away from Belt especially since Cron is a below average first baseman and the Giants would be vulnerable on the right side of the infield as a result.

The Red Sox make particular sense because of the high ceiling, major league ready pitching they possess in Allen Webster (plus-plus fastball and plus control) and  Matt Barnes (plus-plus fastball, plus curve). The Giants really need at least one of these pitchers, They can't have both, but if they could swing a deal for either one of them they would quickly solve some of the issues they will face with the starting rotation next year.

I like the Pirates because of Nick Kingham who is performing well in double - A with a plus fastball, curveball, and change up. He could easily slide into the rotation as he is performing better than any of the Giants current options. I am more attracted to Josh Bell, however,  a switch-hitter with plus power and average from both sides of the plate. He is farther away in high A, but he has a higher ceiling than anyone in the Giants system other than Kyle Crick or Clayton Blackburn. The thought of him peppering the left field bleachers is tantalizing in my mind

The Cardinals are like the Red Sox in that they can offer big league ready pitching in Wacha (untouchable), Carlos Martinez, and Trevor Rosenthal, Although these are intriguing prospects they are hardly in the market for Pence because of their established outfield and superstar prospect in Oscar Taveras.

The Tigers excite me the most because of one man: Nick Castellanos. This move only works if Pence is willing to return after being traded, but Castellanos could be ready to fill left field next year and he has a plus bat right now with plus-plus potential. His power is wirey at the moment but as he develops he could have plus raw power in his prime. An outfield with Castellanos, Pagan, and Pence next year would be a huge improvement to anything they have had in the last few years.

Although both of the Giants I talked about today are unlikely to move they are too much fun to talk about and that's what this blog is about. I encourage any and all comments. Please continue to follow A Giant Family and spread the word!

Trade Deadline - Part 2

I initially planned on writing about the Giants possibilities with dealing their bullpen arms. However, in light of the recent promotions I think it more pertinent to evaluate Brett Pill and Roger Kieschnick and what their promotions might mean.

The official roster transactions were: Takana was optioned to triple - A Fresno and Abreau was placed on the disabled list because of his knee, an issue that has plagued him since spring training. As a result Pill looks like he will have another shot in the big leagues and Roger Kieschnick  will make his major league debut.

Brett Pill was drafted by the Giants out of California State University Fullerton in 2006 in the seventh round. Pill spent four full seasons working his way through the minor league system from 2007-2011, finally getting his shot in the big leagues in 2012. His batting average has steadily increased from .266-.312  since his first full season in 2007 through his final full minor league season in 2011. He can be "penciled-in" for around twenty home runs each year with his highest season total was 25 in 2011. He has also been a steady run producer topping 100 RBI in 2009 and 2011, he also had 90 in 2007. He doesn't walk much with anywhere from 4.3-6.5% of his at-bats resulting in walks, but "only" strikes out in roughly 15% of his at bats which is regarded as "above average" in today's game by FanGraphs. His breakout year was in 2011 when he hit 25 home runs, 107 RBI, sported a .312 batting average and had a career low 9.4% strike out rate. The Giants have paid attention to Pill's production in the minor leagues and have given him sporadic opportunities with the big league club because of his right-handed power potential, something the Giants can always have more of. However, his lack of consistent playing time and production have limited him to no more than 100 plate appearances in any big league stint.

Roger Kieschnick was drafted in the third round of the 2008 draft out of Texas Tech University. Baseball America rated him as the number nine prospect in the system going into this season and said that his plate discipline had made solid improvements allowing him to get on base more. More importantly, however, his new-found discipline has allowed him to crush mistakes in the zone. Although injuries have plagued him throughout his career, when he started his minor league career he established himself as a middle-of-the-order run producer with mid-twenty home run totals and and .290 batting average. After his first season he was hamstrung by constant injuries and adjustments. He was on pace to re-establish himself in 2012 before he ran into an outfield wall and in 2013 he has been a solid run producer for Fresno.

Brett Pill's role is uncertain to me. Although Brandon Belt has been struggling as of late I would find it hard to believe that the Giants have just now decided that they want to move in a different direction. Especially with postseason dreams dwindling away, Brandon Belt can continue to amass at-bats throughout an entire big league season, this time without the pressure of September and October. What does that mean for Brett Pill? Well, it gives Bruce Bochy the luxury of giving Belt a rest without loosing too much punch at first base. Posey would have been the alternative earlier, but now Posey can remain in the lineup and, ideally, keep potent offensive minded bats at crucial positions. But if the Giants only called up Pill to platoon, than I don't really see the value in that move because conventional wisdom posits that a prospect should continue to develop and accrue at-bats so that when he is in a position to receive regular playing time that the prospect would make an immediate impact. I'm sure the Giants have considered this so maybe they believe that Pill has reached his ceiling and now is his time to stay.

I may not go out and buy a Brett Pill Jersey but I do respect the way he has handled his demotions with maturity and continued to hit the ball hard in triple - A; he has simply earned the right to an opportunity to make a name for himself and an impact at the big league level.

Roger Kieschnick complicates Pill's situation because now left field is closed. The revolving door in left field was covered up by Pagan in the playoffs last season. Now that Pagan is out that fault has been exposed and the Giants know that they need to find a more permanent and effective solution in left. There still may be a bit of a revolving door but I think Kieschnick can expect fairly regular playing time in left field, and this could be a tryout for next season as well. Like many other teams with losing records, they begin to play minor leaguers to evaluate them at the big league level and decide if they can be effective players for any duration of time.

I think it might be easier to predict numbers for Kieschnick than for Pill because I expect Kieschnick to receive more regular playing time. My bet for Pill would be a .260 batting average, 4 homeruns and 15 RBI assuming he receives even semi-regular playing time. I will be a bit more optimistic with Kieschnick because I like the reports I have read on him and his ability. The key? Stay in the zone, he struggles at times to protect the outer half of the plate, and he will chase down below the zone as well. I predict a .280 batting average, 8 homeruns and 40 RBI. He does bat left handed so his power numbers may dip and he only has less than half of the season left so he may be a bit limited.

Hopefully tomorrow I can propose some trades that may be worthwhile for the Giants to consider. I'll focus on Pence, Romo, and Lopez. Stay tuned, thanks for reading, and spread the word!

Monday, July 29, 2013

Trade Deadline Deals - Part One

As the Giants sink further and further below the .500 mark the idea that they miss the playoffs and finish with their worst record since 2008 becomes increasingly realistic (and painful). I, as I'm sure many other Giants fans have begun to, frequently consider their options at the trade deadline and the imminent future. Looking at 2014, I fully expect the Giants to be competitive both within the division and the National League, although they are not without questions. Second base is a concern as Marco Scutruo's range and health diminish, Pablo will be under heavy scrutiny (although his upcoming free agency should be a sufficient impetus to shed a few pounds), Pagan's return from hamstring surgery, the enduring left field quandary, and Hunter Pence's free agent status. As for the pitching staff, a bullpen can be relatively easily to remedy and I fully expect Brian Sabean to employ his frugal and ingenious tactics to compile a solid 'pen. Questions about starting pitching persist as Zito and Lincecum approach free agency and Ryan Voglesong's age climbs.

*Phew* Before I wrote that paragraph I thought the Giants would still be fairly established next year, but after I completed it I am oddly not as confident.

I will analyze most of these situations later in the year and into the offseason, but in my mind there are five possible moves to consider: Lincecum, Zito, Pence, Javier Lopez, and Sergio Romo. I chose these five players after considering their, and the rest of the roster's, relative value on the market, their production, and potential suitors.

Today I will look at the starting pitchers that could attract attention...

Lincecum is an intriguing player because of how unique he is. He was unique in high school, college, the minors and when he arrived in the big leagues. His credentials are widely unparalleled - two Cy Young awards (including four top ten finishes), two World Series rings, two strikeout titles, a four time all-star and a no-hitter - and don't forget Giants fans love him. Many would argue that if one was to cover his name and purely look at what he has accomplished, those accomplishments would put him into the Hall of Fame - however that is a discussion for another day. I unfortunately do not have the manpower to compile a list of pitchers who share those same accolades, if anyone reading this knows, please share, I would love to know.
The questions teams also raise when evaluating Lincecum is his new found "versatility" as a pitcher. Coming off of a dominant post-season as a reliever many teams may be attracted to him for that reason. I personally believe that the Giants caught lightning in a bottle by putting Lincecum in the bullpen and I do not think that he would enjoy the same success if they were to try again. Many teams are struggling to quantify his ceiling as a reliever because they have not been able to scout him out of the 'pen - don't wait for that to happen either. Because of the dearth of scouting opportunities and the low demand for long relievers I do not see many teams trading for him as a reliever.

As a starter Lincecum has received relentless attention and scrutiny because of his high ERA and walk totals coupled with low inning totals. He has been surprisingly durable throwing over 200 innings from 2008-2011 (with a high of 227), but I wouldn't attribute his woes to fatigue because of his "rubber arm." Although most of these statistics are not new, his home run total has increased each year since 2009 with a peak of 23 in 2012. He has always had a fairly high walk total (2.7-4.4 walks per nine innings), but his days as a perpetual strike out king neutralized his walks. Now with a consistent velocity of 89-93 miles per hour and poor location his walks have become a glaring area of concern. In 2009 his WHIP was an astonishing 1.04, however since then it has slowly climbed from 1.27, 1.20, 1.47, and this year 1.38.

In summary: Lincecum's versatility and his improvements from last year to this year, especially his improvements of late (barring his start against Cincinnati on the 22nd), and his fame within the baseball community make him an attractive option. However, what the Giants will receive and can reasonably ask are in question. Because of his struggles most teams will be weary to give up even a mid-level prospect for what most consider to barely a number five starter. IF the Giants were to deal him they could first negotiate on who will eat the rest of his contract and then they could possibly expect a prospect like Mookie Betts (Red Sox), Chen Lee (Indians), Will Clinard (Tigers), or Michael Belfiore (Oriels). Although all of these names will vary according to what the other team projects Lincecum will accomplish and the the dollars either side is willing to eat.

Personally, I believe that Tim will remain a Giant this season. He has forever endeared himself to this fan base and regardless of how this season ends and what the future holds I believe he will remembered for his incredible success. I feel comfortable saying that he is one of the most popular Giants of all time and the front office must consider those who buy tickets when they consider dealing Tim, although I think that in a successful franchise emotion should play a minimal role. Also a very important aspect of the future negotiations is the compensatory draft pick in the 2014 amateur draft the Giants would receive should they tender him a $13.5 million qualifying offer and he turn it down. That draft pick could be more valuable in the eyes of the front office than any return they would get for him in a trade, (Tim's options at the end of the year will be evaluated at the end of the year in another post.)

And then there is Barry Zito. Zito's contract is up at the end of the year, however he does have a team option for 2014. His hefty contract and abhorring home road splits make him an unattractive solution to many playoff-bound teams. He will unquestionably remain a Giant through this year.

Other starting pitching options on the market include Cliff Lee, Ervin Santana, Jake Peavy, Josh Johnson, Phil Hughes, Edinson Volquez, Joe Saunders, Yovani Gallardo, Kyle Loshe and Jeff Samardzija.

Tomorrow I will publish my thoughts on the Giants bullpen arms. Stay tuned and thanks for reading.

Sunday, July 28, 2013

The Train Ride to AT&T Park

This past Tuesday a friend and I were on our way to the Giants versus Reds double header, the first such double header since 2004 against the Montreal Expos. As we boarded the train we quickly began to lament the recent and prolonged struggles of the Giants. Acting on the assumption that Brian Sabean would one day grant us his proxy, we began to evaluate all possible solutions Mr. Sabean and his team of experts have apparently not considered.

In the midst of our debate on Gary Brown, the once future all-star for the Giants, we were interrupted by a man sitting behind offering his two cents on Brown (that he wouldn't play this year at AT&T, he might not ever play in a Giants uniform). The more he talked, the more knowledgeable he sounded and we eventually learned he was an area scout for an MLB team. My friend and I exchanged bewildered glances and dove into a fruitful and insightful conversation any baseball enthusiast could appreciate. It was a conversation that I will remember for a long, long time.

I used to consider myself a baseball enthusiast, but today I more accurately refer to myself as a baseball nerd; a harsh reality that set in when I found myself reading high school scouting reports from 2009. My credentials for "Baseball Nerd" status include: watching each and every Giants game, following minor league baseball and pin-stripping my bedroom walls to resemble a Yankee uniform when I went through my unavoidable "Yankee Phase."

That conversation and my love of baseball prompted me to write a blog concerning the San Francisco Giants, their minor league affiliates and all other topics baseball. I invite any and all to read, comment on, and follow A Giants Family: a blog by a baseball fan - for baseball fans that will be published Sunday nights.