Wednesday, August 5, 2015

The Emergence of Matt Duffy

After a prolonged absence from the blogosphere "A Giant Family" will return to the forefront of minor and major league baseball evaluation!

My goal for the next few posts is to take a look at how some of the Giants' home-grown talent has progressed from questionably selected draft picks into all-star talent, a look at the Giants' draft selections from the 2014 and 2015, and any other topics that may come along. As usual, if there is anything of particular interest that people would like to discuss, please feel free to comment or respond to these posts.

The trio I'll focus on will be Matt Duffy, Joe Panik, and Brandon Crawford. Together these young infielders have formed the foundation of the Giants' sustainable future. Although they do not have the flash of many of the young players crashing upon the shores of baseball in this unparalleled talent wave, they nevertheless represent shrewd, creative, and successful drafting practices that have allowed the Giants to win three of the last five world series.

I'll start with Matt Duffy. Drafted as an 18th round pick out of California State University at Long Beach he was unheralded as the 568th overall selection. On the surface he possessed little more than fringe-average tools across the board and he didn't have the prolific college career we, as fans, typically associate with MLB draft picks. Here are his collegiate statistics taken from McCovey Chronicles:
2010 (freshman year): .244/.245/.291, 0 HR
2011: .266/.298/.290, 0 HR
2012: .244/.336/.289, 0 HR

However, these numbers are a bit misleading. Coming off his sophomore year he went to the prestigious Cape Cod league where he finished third in the circuit with a .348 batting average after making small, but effective adjustments regarding how far back he stood from the plate. Moving back a bit helped him avoid getting jammed and allowed him to extend his arms and see the pitch longer. His growth as a hitter was soon stunted as a stomach aliment plagued him and cost him 10 pounds he could ill afford to lose. All of this played into the Giants' fortunate selection.

A preliminary analysis of Duffy's minor league numbers present an intriguing prospect. Standard statistical evaluations would display a steady producer, but little more than a system player or versatile utility man. In two years he played across four levels, played in 248 games and came to bat 1087 times. In this time he hit 13 home runs, stole a respectable 55 bags, posted a solid 1.21:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio, and an impressive .304/.387/.413 triple slash line. 

However, a more thorough statistical analysis presents a consistently above average hitter who did many things well. Despite never hitting for much power in his minor league career, he consistently posted OPS's that fell in the "above average" category (as determined by fangraphs) .647, .832, .823, .852, and .842 at A-, A, A+, and AAA, respectively.  His minor league career OPS stands at .791.

I few figures I'll point out that might have indicated Duffy's future success:

wRC+ (weighted runs created): Per fangraphs, "a statistic which attempts to credit a hitter for the value of each outcome rather than treating all hits or times on base equally, while also controlling for park effects..." Furthermore, it attempts to measure each player against an average of 100. Every point above or below 100 corresponds to 1 or 2 percent above or below average. Duffy's minor league wRC+ stands at an impressive 123.8 (23.8% above average). By minimizing his strikeouts, maximizing his contact and walk rates, and running the bases well he's turned himself into a solid regular at the major league level. 

While fangraphs doesn't have stratified ranking designations for BABIP or slugging percentage, "average", "above average", etc, they do provide league averages. MLB average for BABIP and slugging are .298 and .398, respectively. Duffy currently stands at .356 and .465. Both of these figures are significantly above average and in line with his minor league numbers (career .329 BABIP and .414 slugging). Duffy's career numbers also fall significantly above league averages and at this point we get a pretty good idea as to what made him successful. He doesn't strike out excessively, consistently puts the pall in play, pounds the gaps for extra bases, and can run the bases effectively.

Not long ago Duffy would have been branded as someone who couldn't fit the third base prototype. While front office executives still look for power production out of their third basemen, we are seeing more players come up in the mold of Duffy. For every Todd Frazier, Josh Donaldson, or Manny Machado, there's a Jung Ho Kang, Justin Turner or Matt Carpenter. Guys who have the ability to be productive big leaguers by getting on base and putting the ball and play.

Duffy could have been selected by 29 other teams and 567 picks earlier. However, the Giants' scouting staff found the needle in the hay stack and what they have is a rookie third basemen playing at a rookie of the year level.

Stay tuned for more articles detailing home grown talent and go Giants!

Monday, August 3, 2015

Carlos Correa

Although this blog is dedicated primarily to the intricacies of the San Francisco Giants and its minor league affiliates, I was recently struck by the Astros' young phenom, Carlos Correa. Drafted number one overall in the 2012 MLB draft Correa was immediately regarded as an impact talent and vaulted to the top of prospect rankings, earning himself lofty comparisons to the likes of Alex Rodriguez or Cal Ripken Jr. and he has been impressive in each game since being drafted.

With the Astros seemingly in contention for the first time in a decade Correa has proved to be a force in the middle of the diamond. Observers of the game are already saying that he is one of, if not, the best shortstops in all of baseball and the purpose of this post will be to analyze the merits of that statement.

Correa's numbers are impressive thus far into his major league career. Through 47 games he owns a .299/.348/.567 triple slash line, 12 home runs, 5 stolen bases, .267 ISO, .321 BABIP, and a 153 wRC+.

Furthermore, he leads all American League shortstops lead in home runs at 12 and if he had enough at-bats to qualify, he would rank 3rd in batting average, 2nd in on-base percentage, lead in slugging, and 2nd in WAR at 2.6 (!).

These numbers are flat-out incredible. Despite playing only two months worth of games, he ranks among the league leaders in every major statistical category and his advanced metrics are equally as impressive.

Some intriguing metrics to consider: .915 OPS, wOBA (linearly weighted value measuring a player's contribution each at-bat, .320 is average) of .390, Line Drive percentage of 22.1% (average is 21%), 20.5% HR/FB ratio (average is 9.5%), and an equitable 36.2%, 33.9%, and 29.9% pull middle and oppo percentages, relatively speaking. Each of these numbers is impressive in their own right, but to have a rookie put up numbers like this is almost startling.

Now there is an infinite number of statistics we could look at to further validate his precociousness, but these standard and advanced numbers paint a picture of a shortstop who is hitting for a high average with significant power production with the ability to consistently get on base, run the bases well and use the whole field. Although he doesn't have enough at-bats to qualify for the league lead in many of these statistics, it is still startlingly impressive that he has the ability to produce at such a high level despite his relative inexperience and age differential.

Now to look at his fielding statistics. In 414.1 innings he has six errors which corresponds to a .969 fielding percentage. Again not enough attempts to qualify, but good enough for a top-10 level percentage.

UZR, one of the most common and widely available fielding statistics establishes a "run-value" for defense that seeks to establish how many runs a player has saved because of his defense. There are four different components to this statistic, including: Outfield Arm Runs, Double-Play Runs, Range Runs, and Error Runs. However, given Correa's small sample size at short, UZR isn't going to be as accurate as we would like and only truly becomes solid after a few years of accumulated data. Nevertheless, the figure is compelling. Despite having only a small sample size his 11.6 UZR/150 grades out into the second highest category after only a few months.

Similarly, DRS (defensive runs saved) seeks to measure how many runs above or below average defensive players are. Thus far, Correa has saved three defensive runs which ranks within the top ten of all major league shortstops which is again compounded by his short stay.

Correa has been regarded as a high quality prospect since he was drafted and immediately slotted into the upper echelon of minor league prospects. His ability to hit in games was never questioned and he posted a .313/.392/.491 career triple slash line in four minor league seasons. He has a 70 grade (out of a possible 80) arm that would play any where on the diamond which led many scouts to project a move to third. But to his credit, and according to various reports, he has worked diligently on his conditioning to ensure that he was quick enough to play short. His power hasn't always showed in the minors and never hit more than 10 home runs in any single year. The catch here is that he hit those 10 this year when his power was showing in game sand he lost nearly a half season after breaking his leg sliding into a base last year.

Correa stands today as one of the brightest starts in this wave of young talent. Shortstop already has a dearth of impact bats as most clubs are comfortable sacrificing a degree of offensive potential to gain a degree of defensive certainty. However, Correa is a unique blend of player who has defensive ability and a potent bat.

Many clamored for an all-star selection this year and if he were to not play another game this year his numbers might still merit and all-star selection. If he continues this meteoric rise he is a perennial all-star anchoring an improving Astros club and even if he doesn't progress much further he is still an above average player. It isn't out of the question that Correa might experience a degree of regression as the league sees him more or if he deals with fatigue coming off a major injury and the wear and tear of a full season, but either way, the Astros have a stud prospect on their hands and is exceeding even some of his most lofty expectations.

Sunday, January 11, 2015

Off-season Moves, or lack-thereof

I know there is a lot to talk about within the game of baseball, but I don’t have nearly enough time to dive into everything that has happened since my last post. However, I would like to address one aspect of the offseason: the Giants and their inability to land big names. The Giants’ front office, I believe, has a specific idea of who they are and the type of players they want to attract. They are well aware of the winning culture they’ve built and the expectation that accompanies this.

The Giants have a number of question marks entering this season, as most teams do, but they seem to be in the running for everyone from Yoan Moncada to Ben Zobrist. But it seems that they fall short each time, even though they are competitive all the way to end.

My take on the situation would be the following: the Giants know who they are and what they have and they know when to walk away. The current landscape of baseball almost requires teams to overpay for free agents and big trades. However, the Giants appear unwilling to commit to a deal that isn’t on their terms. I think this is something to applaud, really. Outside of the Aaron Roward or Barry Zito deals, the Giants have avoided any financially crippling contracts and have appeared to be the winners on almost all of their trades. Rather than bemoan each time the Giants fall short, it may be fair to recognize the restraint the front office has exercised.

Jon Lester was a good for the Cubs, but he may not have been for the Giants. Ben Zobrist would have been a great piece for left field, or the rest of the diamond, but the Giants aren’t in a position to take on Yunel Escobar as well.

I’ll be the first to recognize that it’s tough to watch the Giants fall short on guys who are in a position to help them win, but it’s important to recognize that they aren’t making deals on the terms of another team. When deals are made, the Giants win and I think that is worth waiting for.

I realize this may sound like an angry Giants fan putting the “I broke up with her, she didn’t break up with me” spin on things (and I apologize for the less than eloquent analogy for any potential employers that may be reading this) but I think it is important to be patient and wait for the right deal to roll around.

The downside to this is that the Giants have significant “ifs” going into the season. We don’t know if Belt is going to bounce back from an injury plagued season to hit the 30 home runs we’ve been promised. We don’t know if Pagan can sit atop the lineup like he has in the past. How is Panik going to handle a full season when pitchers will inevitably adjust to him? Can Posey continue to handle the rigors of the catcher position? Will McGee pack any punch at the hot corner?

Giants fans will have to live with these questions, but balance them with the confidence that they have the talent to compete without any big moves. I think that is a fair trade and front office stability that most teams can only dream of. 

Thursday, August 14, 2014

Posey's Transition

Hello everyone! Apologies for the delay in posts, it has been a crazy few months.
Getting right down to business - Tim Kawakami recently wrote about Buster Posey transitioning to third base next year and I would like to voice my opinion in support of this motion.

For any number of reasons, and rightly so, head injuries have been garnering greater attention in Major League Baseball. This can possibly be attributed to other professional sporting organizations, like the NFL or NHL, who are putting player safety at the forefront of their agendas, and Major League Baseball is following suit. One could also argue that with an increasing number of players who are dealing with concussions has forced MLB to take action. Stars like Joe Mauer, Mike Matheny and Justin Morneau have all dealt with concussion issues that called their careers into question at one time or another. As the game becomes more dynamic and pitchers seem to throw harder, fans must also be concerned with pitches to the head. Marlon Byrd took a fastball to the face as a Cub, Mariners farmhand D.J. Peterson lost half a season to a broken jaw after been struck by an awry fastball, and Mets fans frequently wake up in cold sweats when they remember Mike Piazza took a Roger Clemens fastball to the head and seemed to momentarily lose consciousness.

For these reasons and many others, namely it is the right decision for player safety, Major League Baseball issued guidelines for concussion testing and on field evaluations on March 29, 2011. Since these rules were erected MLB has seen scores of players sidelined by concussions. Our own Hector Sanchez and Brandon Belt have spent time on the seven day concussion disabled list and these events cause concern to loom ominously over the heads of all baseball fans.

In a circuitous motion we have finally returned to the Buster Posey point. Posey is a cornerstone of the Giants franchise, winner of the Rookie of the Year and MVP awards, as well as a two-time World Series Champion. The Giants simply would not be in their current position or have enjoyed their recent success had they chosen, say, Tim Beckham or Kyle Skipworth with their number five selection in the 2008 first year player draft. He handles the media attention with aplomb and his humble, down to Earth personality endear him to fans and teammates alike, thus ensuring himself and his family peace of mind and security when he earned his nine year, $167 million contract.

With all of this being said, I think it is time to move Posey out from behind the plate. Each night that passes he seems to take another Earth rocking shot to the helmet. With each bat of the eye he needs to clear his cloudy head and quite the deafening ringing of his ears, I become more and more nervous. Too many other catchers have seen their careers fall apart due to concussions and I do not want to see that happen to Posey either.

Any move that would hypothetically take place would need Buster’s blessing because he has all the leverage. Fans love him, he has had tremendous success, his value is maximized behind the plate and he is a respected veteran. However, I have to believe having Bruce Bochy, a manager who is very familiar with the rigors of being a big league catcher, would be eager to support such a transition.

Such a move isn’t without precedent. The Astros moved Craig Biggio out from catcher at his age-26 season and went onto play the rest of his prolific career at second base. Joe Torre moved off of catcher for his age-30 season and went onto win and MVP the following year and hit .295 in 1306 games away from catcher. Brian Downing moved off during his age-30 season and he proceeded to hit .269 (compared to .260 in 675 games as a catcher) and club 219 homers (compared to 47 homeruns exclusively as a catcher) while playing away from catcher.

Posey is on track to set a career low in batting average and OPS (excluding his injury shortened 2011) following a 2013 year that saw him set career lows in batting average and OPS (excluding 2011, and to be fair, batting.294 in 2013 isn’t a catastrophe). In 342 plate appearances this year as a catcher he has sported a .259/.322/.435 slash line, compared to .392/.444/.541 as a first basemen. This is a small sample size, of course, but he has displayed a similar trend throughout his (also brief) career, except for 2012 when he was MVP and his line was absurd across the board.

The logistics of the move are intriguing as well. If Pablo walks at the end of the year (which I would argue he should) third base would be left vacant, in addition to the gaping holes in left field, closer, second base, and a back of the rotation starter. Payroll is stretched dangerously thin and without much wiggle room. Not to say this decision should be based off of dollars and cents, because it shouldn't, but it would allow the Giants to be more efficient with the dollars they already have tied up. Andrew Susac and Hector Sanchez could then create a very attractive catcher platoon (see the Oakland Athletics).

To be fair, Posey has no major league experience at third base, but in college he literally played every position on the diamond. Additionally, he was recruited as a shortstop and didn't commit to catching full-time until his sophomore year at Florida State. Basically, his athleticism has never been in question, but rather an asset to someone (essentially) learning to catch on the fly.

In truth, part of what make Posey valuable is that he plays a position for which there is usually a dearth of successful hitters who can sustain their success. More often than not, they succumb to the rigors of the position. If we were to move Posey right now to first or third base, he wouldn't necessarily fit the “profile” of a corner infielder. However, there are two counter points to this argument; one, we would hope to see an uptick in his production after moving away from catcher, and two, the profiles of the corners is changing. Guys like Chris Davis don’t grow on trees and we are starting to see guys like Matt Carpenter, James Loney, Conor Gillaspie, and Chris Johnson fill in at corner slots.


I am confident Posey could adapt to play third and put up slightly better numbers. I think if he were to slash .295/.375/.490 with 24-27 homeruns and 90 runs batted in, numbers within his capability, he would be an all-star third basemen for the Giants. I rest my case. 

Thursday, June 19, 2014

San Francisco Giants Draft 2014

Alas, it is finally time to review the Giants 2014 draft. Although it is a bit premature to review a draft until all the players sign, I will still take a look at some potential impact players.

At number 14 overall, the Giants had their highest selection since 2009, when they selected Zack Wheeler with the number six overall selection. In a draft deep in arms, the Giants were in a strong position to select a player who could immediately bolster a fairly weak farm system. Remaining on the board when the 14th pick arrived, the Giants had a number of available arms, high school and college, that had relatively high ceilings, as well as a number of high school bats who were raw, but had great upside, and a handful of college bats who were projectable, but didn't have extraordinarily high ceilings. They choose Tyler Beede.

Beede will not be able to sing until Vanderbilt has finished the College World Series, which could be before the end of the weekend if they lose two in a row, or another few weeks if they continue to win. Beede was previously selected in the first round back in 2011 by the Blue Jays, but he elected to attend Vanderbilt. He struggled a bit as a freshmen, but earned SEC pitcher of the year in 2013 but proceeded to have a tough summer with Team USA. He is athletic and strong at 6 foot 4, 215 pounds and flashes three potential plus pitches. His fastball sits 92-94 and peaks at 97, his changeup (a staple of the Giants organization) is plus and his curveball, 80-81 mph, is also plus. He also has a very loose personality, and a burgeoning rap career, which should fit well into the San Francisco community.

He has been an enigma to scouts who see his electric stuff, but he has average control and below average command. If he can piece it all together he could be an ace, but he cannot continue to walk five batters per game if he wants to succeed in the big leagues. I think he fits very well into an organization that has successfully developed a number of pitchers and was an excellent selection by the Giants.

After Beede I thought the draft went south. With their second pick the Giants selected Aramis Garcia, a catcher who has average power and is average behind the plate, despite their current catching options (Posey, Sanchez, Susac). Next they selected Dylan Davis who has good power but is average in the field and has a below average hit tool. I liked the following picks of Logan Webb, a hard throwing and athletic prep pitcher, and Sam Coonrod, a hard throwing but raw college pitcher from Southern Illinois. Here the Giants have two project pitchers with high ceilings, but need time.

I would have liked to have seen the Giants go after high ceiling, malleable players because of their shortage in the minors. I thought they played it safe among hitters, of whom they have very few potential impact players in the farm system. I thought they did a good job selecting pitchers who have upside and projection, but overall I though the draft was average. Above all else, a team cannot miss on their first round selection, which I do not believe the Giants did. I like to see teams go after high ceiling, impact athletes later in the draft, but I didn't see that with the Giants at all. I still see the hitters as a glaring weakness in their system that I didn't see addressed in the draft.

It will be fun to keep an eye on all of the new Giants and follow them on their paths to the big leagues, and congratulations to all players who were drafted by the Giants and everyone else (yes, event the Dodgers)

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

MLB Draft Updates

Sorry to everyone for taking so long to finally get a post up about the MLB draft. As of today, 21 first round picks have signed, excluding the competitive balance and supplementary rounds. Notable among the signees are top overall pick Brady Aiken, fellow high school arm Tyler Kolek and fellow top five picks Kyle Schwarber and Nick Gordon. Also notable are Derek Hill out of the local high school Elk Grove High and Stanford product Alex Blandino. According to draft expert Jim Callis, all first round picks are expected to sign, including our very own Tyler Beede.

Surprises: Kyle Schwarber was not an anticipated top-five pick, but when top arms Jeff Hoffman and Erick Feede went down with Tommy John procedures the Cubs didn't have a player they loved. As a result they selected Schwarber and singed him to an under-slot deal. The Cubs continue to collect an impressive arsenal of young hitters, and with the money they saved on Schwarber, and their second round pick (a college senior) Jake Stinnet they were able to heavily pursue prep arms later in the draft. Other surprises were Kodi Medeiros rising to number twelve with the Brewers. Apparently Medeiros wowed the Brewers' front office brass at a private workout where he was touching 97 from the left side with solid athleticism and the makings of future plus pitches with his slider and changeup. Notable players who fell were Jacob Gatewood (Brewers, 41) due to hitting concerns, although he flashes the most power in the draft, Derek Fisher (Houston, 37) who battled injures and struggled to hit his stride during the year and Sean Reid-Foley (Jays, 49) who fell due to signablilty concerns.

Teams Who Impressed: Although it will be impossible to tell which teams had the best haul of prospects for another few years, a handful of teams standout for a successful draft: the D-Backs, Blue Jays and Brewers.

D-Backs - The D-Backs nabbed Touki Toussaint at number 16 overall and landed one of the best athletes of the draft. A soccer player growing up, Toussaint has little mileage on his arm because of the time he spent on the soccer field, but nevertheless he boasts a mid-90s fastball and the best curveball in the draft. As a premium athlete he has as much upside as any player in the draft and creates a trio of high ceiling pitching prospects in Archie Bradley and Braden Shipley. Later in the draft the D-Backs targeted Marcus Wilson, a high upside athlete and Matt Railey, a left handed prep bat with a great deal of power potential. I though this was a solid draft because of the high upside arms the D-Backs have accumulated in addition to a few high upside prep players.

The Blue Jays had two first round picks and put themselves in a position to walk away with solid talent. Jeff Hoffman was a candidate for the number one overall pick before he succumbed to Tommy John surgery, but the success rate of these operations mollified some of the Jays' concerns. Hoffman touts both a plus fastball and curveball in addition to an above average change up. He has the potential to be a front line starter. Max Pentecost was their second, first round pick as compensation for failing to sign Phil Bickford in last year's draft. Pentecost will most likely stay behind the plate and has average arm strength and receiving skills. He has above average speed for a backstop and has had great success in the batters box. He was the MVP of the Cape Cod league and led the nation in hits and ranked second in average and has average power potential. Finally, the signed Sean Reid-Foley who fell to the second round because of signability concerns. He has an above average fastball and curveball with an average changeup and control. Overall, this draft impressed because of the quality and quantity of the prospects they nabbed at the top of the draft.

In my opinion, the club that did the best was the Brewers. They landed three premium high school athletes with as much upside as any in the class. Kodi Medeiros from Hawaii was the first selected. Medeiros impressed the Brewers at a private workout with a plus fastball and slider from and unorthodox arm slot. Jacob Gatewood has as much power as any player in the draft and gained national recognition for winning the home run derby at Citi Field. His contact issues caused him to fall, but should he solve his problems he could be a 30+ homerun threat at the major league level. Some scouts project him outgrowing shortstop, but that remains to be seen. And lastly, Monte Harrison, who scouts considered the be the best athlete in this years draft. He presently has above average tools with his hit and power and plus with his speed and arm. He struggles with pitch recognition because he split time on the basketball court and football field. Some thought he would be a tough sign away from his dual football, baseball scolarship to Nebraska, but he signed quickly. All three are risky picks, but if they materialize, Milwaukee will have landed three perennial all-stars.

I hope everyone enjoyed the festivities of the draft and now its time to get fired up for the next one.

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

The Replay System

As you all are aware of by now, I hope, Major League Baseball has instituted a new instant replay system to increase the accuracy of calls made as well as trying to prevent mistakes from influencing the true outcome of the game. Baseball purists bemoan the new system because it erases the “human element” of the game and prolongs already tiresome three hour games. Purists argue that without the human element there would be no great stories of Jackie Robinson stealing home on Yogi Berra and the Yankees, there would be no classic “punchouts” by umpires and there would be no heated manager versus umpire arguments. Essentially, some of the greatest moments and aspects of baseball would be left by the wayside as high tech changes speed right past the memories of yore.

Everyone else argues that baseball cannot be the only major sport to not employ advanced technology to ensure that the correct, arbitrary calls are made in order to ensure a more perfect game. They argue that while it may be entertaining to watch Earl Weaver get tossed by an umpire, fans won’t appreciate being on the losing end of an egregious call which irreparably influences the outcome of the game.

Thus far 184 calls have been overturned (47.67%), compared to 202 calls upheld (52.33%). Force calls (169) and tag plays (127) have been reviewed the most, while ground rules (2), timing plays (2), stadium boundary calls (2) and touching a base (3) have been reviewed the least. The Cardinals, Orioles and D-Backs have challenged the fewest calls at six apiece, while the Cubs (19) have challenged the most. Your San Francisco Giants have challenged 12.

Since this is a blog I will offer my opinion. I do agree that by this day in age, and with all the changes other sports have made, it is impressive baseball has gone as long as it has without making this change. With that being said and with the technology at hand, baseball really didn't have much of a choice; instant replay was coming one way or another. I really do think it can change the game for the better because I do not want to see the Giants lose game seven of the World Series over a missed tag at the plate. Although I do think the system is a necessary evil, I do not believe that it is perfect, which was an unreasonable expectation anyways.

Although I do not have concrete solutions to some of the problems I have, I would like to highlight a few things I believe can be adjusted. I do think that many challenges last too long, especially since there isn't a game clock to reset. Also, I think that each team should have one review, no tack-backsies if you get it right or wrong, simply one challenge; that way we can still keep a small piece of the game “old-fashioned”, but I don’t think that is a realistic request either. One of my pet peeves with the system is I cannot stand it when the replays are shown in-game on the scoreboards while the call is reviewed in New York. I think that directly undermines the umpires who made the call, right or wrong, when many fans can’t even see the scoreboard itself very well.

I do miss the player and manager arguments with the umpires that seem to have disappeared from the game, there really was nothing like watching someone get run from a game. And most importantly I want to acknowledge the umpires who do a thankless job with zero recognition. I think the replay system has confirmed how talented and precise the umps really are and they do a great job and without them the game we all love wouldn't exist.


Here’s to the great umpires of major league baseball and the continued refinement of the replay system.