Tuesday, May 27, 2014

The Replay System

As you all are aware of by now, I hope, Major League Baseball has instituted a new instant replay system to increase the accuracy of calls made as well as trying to prevent mistakes from influencing the true outcome of the game. Baseball purists bemoan the new system because it erases the “human element” of the game and prolongs already tiresome three hour games. Purists argue that without the human element there would be no great stories of Jackie Robinson stealing home on Yogi Berra and the Yankees, there would be no classic “punchouts” by umpires and there would be no heated manager versus umpire arguments. Essentially, some of the greatest moments and aspects of baseball would be left by the wayside as high tech changes speed right past the memories of yore.

Everyone else argues that baseball cannot be the only major sport to not employ advanced technology to ensure that the correct, arbitrary calls are made in order to ensure a more perfect game. They argue that while it may be entertaining to watch Earl Weaver get tossed by an umpire, fans won’t appreciate being on the losing end of an egregious call which irreparably influences the outcome of the game.

Thus far 184 calls have been overturned (47.67%), compared to 202 calls upheld (52.33%). Force calls (169) and tag plays (127) have been reviewed the most, while ground rules (2), timing plays (2), stadium boundary calls (2) and touching a base (3) have been reviewed the least. The Cardinals, Orioles and D-Backs have challenged the fewest calls at six apiece, while the Cubs (19) have challenged the most. Your San Francisco Giants have challenged 12.

Since this is a blog I will offer my opinion. I do agree that by this day in age, and with all the changes other sports have made, it is impressive baseball has gone as long as it has without making this change. With that being said and with the technology at hand, baseball really didn't have much of a choice; instant replay was coming one way or another. I really do think it can change the game for the better because I do not want to see the Giants lose game seven of the World Series over a missed tag at the plate. Although I do think the system is a necessary evil, I do not believe that it is perfect, which was an unreasonable expectation anyways.

Although I do not have concrete solutions to some of the problems I have, I would like to highlight a few things I believe can be adjusted. I do think that many challenges last too long, especially since there isn't a game clock to reset. Also, I think that each team should have one review, no tack-backsies if you get it right or wrong, simply one challenge; that way we can still keep a small piece of the game “old-fashioned”, but I don’t think that is a realistic request either. One of my pet peeves with the system is I cannot stand it when the replays are shown in-game on the scoreboards while the call is reviewed in New York. I think that directly undermines the umpires who made the call, right or wrong, when many fans can’t even see the scoreboard itself very well.

I do miss the player and manager arguments with the umpires that seem to have disappeared from the game, there really was nothing like watching someone get run from a game. And most importantly I want to acknowledge the umpires who do a thankless job with zero recognition. I think the replay system has confirmed how talented and precise the umps really are and they do a great job and without them the game we all love wouldn't exist.


Here’s to the great umpires of major league baseball and the continued refinement of the replay system. 

No comments:

Post a Comment