Thursday, August 14, 2014

Posey's Transition

Hello everyone! Apologies for the delay in posts, it has been a crazy few months.
Getting right down to business - Tim Kawakami recently wrote about Buster Posey transitioning to third base next year and I would like to voice my opinion in support of this motion.

For any number of reasons, and rightly so, head injuries have been garnering greater attention in Major League Baseball. This can possibly be attributed to other professional sporting organizations, like the NFL or NHL, who are putting player safety at the forefront of their agendas, and Major League Baseball is following suit. One could also argue that with an increasing number of players who are dealing with concussions has forced MLB to take action. Stars like Joe Mauer, Mike Matheny and Justin Morneau have all dealt with concussion issues that called their careers into question at one time or another. As the game becomes more dynamic and pitchers seem to throw harder, fans must also be concerned with pitches to the head. Marlon Byrd took a fastball to the face as a Cub, Mariners farmhand D.J. Peterson lost half a season to a broken jaw after been struck by an awry fastball, and Mets fans frequently wake up in cold sweats when they remember Mike Piazza took a Roger Clemens fastball to the head and seemed to momentarily lose consciousness.

For these reasons and many others, namely it is the right decision for player safety, Major League Baseball issued guidelines for concussion testing and on field evaluations on March 29, 2011. Since these rules were erected MLB has seen scores of players sidelined by concussions. Our own Hector Sanchez and Brandon Belt have spent time on the seven day concussion disabled list and these events cause concern to loom ominously over the heads of all baseball fans.

In a circuitous motion we have finally returned to the Buster Posey point. Posey is a cornerstone of the Giants franchise, winner of the Rookie of the Year and MVP awards, as well as a two-time World Series Champion. The Giants simply would not be in their current position or have enjoyed their recent success had they chosen, say, Tim Beckham or Kyle Skipworth with their number five selection in the 2008 first year player draft. He handles the media attention with aplomb and his humble, down to Earth personality endear him to fans and teammates alike, thus ensuring himself and his family peace of mind and security when he earned his nine year, $167 million contract.

With all of this being said, I think it is time to move Posey out from behind the plate. Each night that passes he seems to take another Earth rocking shot to the helmet. With each bat of the eye he needs to clear his cloudy head and quite the deafening ringing of his ears, I become more and more nervous. Too many other catchers have seen their careers fall apart due to concussions and I do not want to see that happen to Posey either.

Any move that would hypothetically take place would need Buster’s blessing because he has all the leverage. Fans love him, he has had tremendous success, his value is maximized behind the plate and he is a respected veteran. However, I have to believe having Bruce Bochy, a manager who is very familiar with the rigors of being a big league catcher, would be eager to support such a transition.

Such a move isn’t without precedent. The Astros moved Craig Biggio out from catcher at his age-26 season and went onto play the rest of his prolific career at second base. Joe Torre moved off of catcher for his age-30 season and went onto win and MVP the following year and hit .295 in 1306 games away from catcher. Brian Downing moved off during his age-30 season and he proceeded to hit .269 (compared to .260 in 675 games as a catcher) and club 219 homers (compared to 47 homeruns exclusively as a catcher) while playing away from catcher.

Posey is on track to set a career low in batting average and OPS (excluding his injury shortened 2011) following a 2013 year that saw him set career lows in batting average and OPS (excluding 2011, and to be fair, batting.294 in 2013 isn’t a catastrophe). In 342 plate appearances this year as a catcher he has sported a .259/.322/.435 slash line, compared to .392/.444/.541 as a first basemen. This is a small sample size, of course, but he has displayed a similar trend throughout his (also brief) career, except for 2012 when he was MVP and his line was absurd across the board.

The logistics of the move are intriguing as well. If Pablo walks at the end of the year (which I would argue he should) third base would be left vacant, in addition to the gaping holes in left field, closer, second base, and a back of the rotation starter. Payroll is stretched dangerously thin and without much wiggle room. Not to say this decision should be based off of dollars and cents, because it shouldn't, but it would allow the Giants to be more efficient with the dollars they already have tied up. Andrew Susac and Hector Sanchez could then create a very attractive catcher platoon (see the Oakland Athletics).

To be fair, Posey has no major league experience at third base, but in college he literally played every position on the diamond. Additionally, he was recruited as a shortstop and didn't commit to catching full-time until his sophomore year at Florida State. Basically, his athleticism has never been in question, but rather an asset to someone (essentially) learning to catch on the fly.

In truth, part of what make Posey valuable is that he plays a position for which there is usually a dearth of successful hitters who can sustain their success. More often than not, they succumb to the rigors of the position. If we were to move Posey right now to first or third base, he wouldn't necessarily fit the “profile” of a corner infielder. However, there are two counter points to this argument; one, we would hope to see an uptick in his production after moving away from catcher, and two, the profiles of the corners is changing. Guys like Chris Davis don’t grow on trees and we are starting to see guys like Matt Carpenter, James Loney, Conor Gillaspie, and Chris Johnson fill in at corner slots.


I am confident Posey could adapt to play third and put up slightly better numbers. I think if he were to slash .295/.375/.490 with 24-27 homeruns and 90 runs batted in, numbers within his capability, he would be an all-star third basemen for the Giants. I rest my case.