Alas, it is finally time to review the Giants 2014 draft. Although it is a bit premature to review a draft until all the players sign, I will still take a look at some potential impact players.
At number 14 overall, the Giants had their highest selection since 2009, when they selected Zack Wheeler with the number six overall selection. In a draft deep in arms, the Giants were in a strong position to select a player who could immediately bolster a fairly weak farm system. Remaining on the board when the 14th pick arrived, the Giants had a number of available arms, high school and college, that had relatively high ceilings, as well as a number of high school bats who were raw, but had great upside, and a handful of college bats who were projectable, but didn't have extraordinarily high ceilings. They choose Tyler Beede.
Beede will not be able to sing until Vanderbilt has finished the College World Series, which could be before the end of the weekend if they lose two in a row, or another few weeks if they continue to win. Beede was previously selected in the first round back in 2011 by the Blue Jays, but he elected to attend Vanderbilt. He struggled a bit as a freshmen, but earned SEC pitcher of the year in 2013 but proceeded to have a tough summer with Team USA. He is athletic and strong at 6 foot 4, 215 pounds and flashes three potential plus pitches. His fastball sits 92-94 and peaks at 97, his changeup (a staple of the Giants organization) is plus and his curveball, 80-81 mph, is also plus. He also has a very loose personality, and a burgeoning rap career, which should fit well into the San Francisco community.
He has been an enigma to scouts who see his electric stuff, but he has average control and below average command. If he can piece it all together he could be an ace, but he cannot continue to walk five batters per game if he wants to succeed in the big leagues. I think he fits very well into an organization that has successfully developed a number of pitchers and was an excellent selection by the Giants.
After Beede I thought the draft went south. With their second pick the Giants selected Aramis Garcia, a catcher who has average power and is average behind the plate, despite their current catching options (Posey, Sanchez, Susac). Next they selected Dylan Davis who has good power but is average in the field and has a below average hit tool. I liked the following picks of Logan Webb, a hard throwing and athletic prep pitcher, and Sam Coonrod, a hard throwing but raw college pitcher from Southern Illinois. Here the Giants have two project pitchers with high ceilings, but need time.
I would have liked to have seen the Giants go after high ceiling, malleable players because of their shortage in the minors. I thought they played it safe among hitters, of whom they have very few potential impact players in the farm system. I thought they did a good job selecting pitchers who have upside and projection, but overall I though the draft was average. Above all else, a team cannot miss on their first round selection, which I do not believe the Giants did. I like to see teams go after high ceiling, impact athletes later in the draft, but I didn't see that with the Giants at all. I still see the hitters as a glaring weakness in their system that I didn't see addressed in the draft.
It will be fun to keep an eye on all of the new Giants and follow them on their paths to the big leagues, and congratulations to all players who were drafted by the Giants and everyone else (yes, event the Dodgers)