Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Trade Deadline - Part 2

I initially planned on writing about the Giants possibilities with dealing their bullpen arms. However, in light of the recent promotions I think it more pertinent to evaluate Brett Pill and Roger Kieschnick and what their promotions might mean.

The official roster transactions were: Takana was optioned to triple - A Fresno and Abreau was placed on the disabled list because of his knee, an issue that has plagued him since spring training. As a result Pill looks like he will have another shot in the big leagues and Roger Kieschnick  will make his major league debut.

Brett Pill was drafted by the Giants out of California State University Fullerton in 2006 in the seventh round. Pill spent four full seasons working his way through the minor league system from 2007-2011, finally getting his shot in the big leagues in 2012. His batting average has steadily increased from .266-.312  since his first full season in 2007 through his final full minor league season in 2011. He can be "penciled-in" for around twenty home runs each year with his highest season total was 25 in 2011. He has also been a steady run producer topping 100 RBI in 2009 and 2011, he also had 90 in 2007. He doesn't walk much with anywhere from 4.3-6.5% of his at-bats resulting in walks, but "only" strikes out in roughly 15% of his at bats which is regarded as "above average" in today's game by FanGraphs. His breakout year was in 2011 when he hit 25 home runs, 107 RBI, sported a .312 batting average and had a career low 9.4% strike out rate. The Giants have paid attention to Pill's production in the minor leagues and have given him sporadic opportunities with the big league club because of his right-handed power potential, something the Giants can always have more of. However, his lack of consistent playing time and production have limited him to no more than 100 plate appearances in any big league stint.

Roger Kieschnick was drafted in the third round of the 2008 draft out of Texas Tech University. Baseball America rated him as the number nine prospect in the system going into this season and said that his plate discipline had made solid improvements allowing him to get on base more. More importantly, however, his new-found discipline has allowed him to crush mistakes in the zone. Although injuries have plagued him throughout his career, when he started his minor league career he established himself as a middle-of-the-order run producer with mid-twenty home run totals and and .290 batting average. After his first season he was hamstrung by constant injuries and adjustments. He was on pace to re-establish himself in 2012 before he ran into an outfield wall and in 2013 he has been a solid run producer for Fresno.

Brett Pill's role is uncertain to me. Although Brandon Belt has been struggling as of late I would find it hard to believe that the Giants have just now decided that they want to move in a different direction. Especially with postseason dreams dwindling away, Brandon Belt can continue to amass at-bats throughout an entire big league season, this time without the pressure of September and October. What does that mean for Brett Pill? Well, it gives Bruce Bochy the luxury of giving Belt a rest without loosing too much punch at first base. Posey would have been the alternative earlier, but now Posey can remain in the lineup and, ideally, keep potent offensive minded bats at crucial positions. But if the Giants only called up Pill to platoon, than I don't really see the value in that move because conventional wisdom posits that a prospect should continue to develop and accrue at-bats so that when he is in a position to receive regular playing time that the prospect would make an immediate impact. I'm sure the Giants have considered this so maybe they believe that Pill has reached his ceiling and now is his time to stay.

I may not go out and buy a Brett Pill Jersey but I do respect the way he has handled his demotions with maturity and continued to hit the ball hard in triple - A; he has simply earned the right to an opportunity to make a name for himself and an impact at the big league level.

Roger Kieschnick complicates Pill's situation because now left field is closed. The revolving door in left field was covered up by Pagan in the playoffs last season. Now that Pagan is out that fault has been exposed and the Giants know that they need to find a more permanent and effective solution in left. There still may be a bit of a revolving door but I think Kieschnick can expect fairly regular playing time in left field, and this could be a tryout for next season as well. Like many other teams with losing records, they begin to play minor leaguers to evaluate them at the big league level and decide if they can be effective players for any duration of time.

I think it might be easier to predict numbers for Kieschnick than for Pill because I expect Kieschnick to receive more regular playing time. My bet for Pill would be a .260 batting average, 4 homeruns and 15 RBI assuming he receives even semi-regular playing time. I will be a bit more optimistic with Kieschnick because I like the reports I have read on him and his ability. The key? Stay in the zone, he struggles at times to protect the outer half of the plate, and he will chase down below the zone as well. I predict a .280 batting average, 8 homeruns and 40 RBI. He does bat left handed so his power numbers may dip and he only has less than half of the season left so he may be a bit limited.

Hopefully tomorrow I can propose some trades that may be worthwhile for the Giants to consider. I'll focus on Pence, Romo, and Lopez. Stay tuned, thanks for reading, and spread the word!

No comments:

Post a Comment