As the Giants sink further and further below the .500 mark the idea that they miss the playoffs and finish with their worst record since 2008 becomes increasingly realistic (and painful). I, as I'm sure many other Giants fans have begun to, frequently consider their options at the trade deadline and the imminent future. Looking at 2014, I fully expect the Giants to be competitive both within the division and the National League, although they are not without questions. Second base is a concern as Marco Scutruo's range and health diminish, Pablo will be under heavy scrutiny (although his upcoming free agency should be a sufficient impetus to shed a few pounds), Pagan's return from hamstring surgery, the enduring left field quandary, and Hunter Pence's free agent status. As for the pitching staff, a bullpen can be relatively easily to remedy and I fully expect Brian Sabean to employ his frugal and ingenious tactics to compile a solid 'pen. Questions about starting pitching persist as Zito and Lincecum approach free agency and Ryan Voglesong's age climbs.
*Phew* Before I wrote that paragraph I thought the Giants would still be fairly established next year, but after I completed it I am oddly not as confident.
I will analyze most of these situations later in the year and into the offseason, but in my mind there are five possible moves to consider: Lincecum, Zito, Pence, Javier Lopez, and Sergio Romo. I chose these five players after considering their, and the rest of the roster's, relative value on the market, their production, and potential suitors.
Today I will look at the starting pitchers that could attract attention...
Lincecum is an intriguing player because of how unique he is. He was unique in high school, college, the minors and when he arrived in the big leagues. His credentials are widely unparalleled - two Cy Young awards (including four top ten finishes), two World Series rings, two strikeout titles, a four time all-star and a no-hitter - and don't forget Giants fans love him. Many would argue that if one was to cover his name and purely look at what he has accomplished, those accomplishments would put him into the Hall of Fame - however that is a discussion for another day. I unfortunately do not have the manpower to compile a list of pitchers who share those same accolades, if anyone reading this knows, please share, I would love to know.
The questions teams also raise when evaluating Lincecum is his new found "versatility" as a pitcher. Coming off of a dominant post-season as a reliever many teams may be attracted to him for that reason. I personally believe that the Giants caught lightning in a bottle by putting Lincecum in the bullpen and I do not think that he would enjoy the same success if they were to try again. Many teams are struggling to quantify his ceiling as a reliever because they have not been able to scout him out of the 'pen - don't wait for that to happen either. Because of the dearth of scouting opportunities and the low demand for long relievers I do not see many teams trading for him as a reliever.
As a starter Lincecum has received relentless attention and scrutiny because of his high ERA and walk totals coupled with low inning totals. He has been surprisingly durable throwing over 200 innings from 2008-2011 (with a high of 227), but I wouldn't attribute his woes to fatigue because of his "rubber arm." Although most of these statistics are not new, his home run total has increased each year since 2009 with a peak of 23 in 2012. He has always had a fairly high walk total (2.7-4.4 walks per nine innings), but his days as a perpetual strike out king neutralized his walks. Now with a consistent velocity of 89-93 miles per hour and poor location his walks have become a glaring area of concern. In 2009 his WHIP was an astonishing 1.04, however since then it has slowly climbed from 1.27, 1.20, 1.47, and this year 1.38.
In summary: Lincecum's versatility and his improvements from last year to this year, especially his improvements of late (barring his start against Cincinnati on the 22nd), and his fame within the baseball community make him an attractive option. However, what the Giants will receive and can reasonably ask are in question. Because of his struggles most teams will be weary to give up even a mid-level prospect for what most consider to barely a number five starter. IF the Giants were to deal him they could first negotiate on who will eat the rest of his contract and then they could possibly expect a prospect like Mookie Betts (Red Sox), Chen Lee (Indians), Will Clinard (Tigers), or Michael Belfiore (Oriels). Although all of these names will vary according to what the other team projects Lincecum will accomplish and the the dollars either side is willing to eat.
Personally, I believe that Tim will remain a Giant this season. He has forever endeared himself to this fan base and regardless of how this season ends and what the future holds I believe he will remembered for his incredible success. I feel comfortable saying that he is one of the most popular Giants of all time and the front office must consider those who buy tickets when they consider dealing Tim, although I think that in a successful franchise emotion should play a minimal role. Also a very important aspect of the future negotiations is the compensatory draft pick in the 2014 amateur draft the Giants would receive should they tender him a $13.5 million qualifying offer and he turn it down. That draft pick could be more valuable in the eyes of the front office than any return they would get for him in a trade, (Tim's options at the end of the year will be evaluated at the end of the year in another post.)
And then there is Barry Zito. Zito's contract is up at the end of the year, however he does have a team option for 2014. His hefty contract and abhorring home road splits make him an unattractive solution to many playoff-bound teams. He will unquestionably remain a Giant through this year.
Other starting pitching options on the market include Cliff Lee, Ervin Santana, Jake Peavy, Josh Johnson, Phil Hughes, Edinson Volquez, Joe Saunders, Yovani Gallardo, Kyle Loshe and Jeff Samardzija.
Tomorrow I will publish my thoughts on the Giants bullpen arms. Stay tuned and thanks for reading.
No comments:
Post a Comment