As the minor league baseball season comes to a close it is time to re-rank the prospects within the Giants minor league system. Here is the link to mlb.com's top 20 Giants' prospects: http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/prospects/watch/y2013/ .
Just a few points of interest: first, in my view, I rank ceiling above "MLB readiness." Second, this list is to encourage debate, not stifle it; I encourage any all all comments.
1) Kyle Crick - Cieling of a future ace, plus fastball and slider 12.45 K/9 rate
2) Clayton Blackburn - Above average fastabll, plus control, WHIP of 1.10, 9.34 K/9
3) Chris Stratton - Plus fastball and slider, great pedigree, 8.39 K/9, 1.33 WHIP, integral part of the Giants future
4) Joe Panik - .257/.333/.347 slash line, excellent bat control, prototypical number two hitter
5) Martin Agosta - Polished, 10.70 K/9, 1.09 WHIP, plus fastball and changeup, part of a talented core of pitchers in the lower minor leagues
6) Mike Kickham - Above average fastball, got his feet wet in the majors this year, one of the few advanced pitching prospects in the Giants' system, may be a better fit in a relief role
7) Heath Hembree - Future closer, plus fastball with a lot of life, struggled with his command, 10.25 K/9
8) Christian Arroyo - Plus hit tool, average power, excellent leadership and work ethic, MVP of the Arizona League, above average plate discpline, .326/.388/.511 slash line
9) Andrew Susac - .252/.359/.454 slash line, 12 homeruns, plus power, needs to refine his hit tool and cut down on strikeouts
10) Gustavo Cabrera - .247/.379/.360 slash line in his first year of professional baseball, plus power, plus speed, comporable to Justin Upton and Byron Buxton at the same age
11) Edwin Escobar - Above average fastball and changeup, 1.14 K/9, 1.10 WHIP, could have an outside shot at a rotation spot after doing well at Double - A Richmond
12) Mac Williamson - Plus power from the right side, advanced hitter but needs to refine his hit tool, .292/.375/.504 slash line, 25 homeruns, .212 ISO
13) Aldaberto Mejia - Above average fastball and plus control, 9.21 K/9, 1.13 WHIP, another member of a very promising group of young arms
14) Ryder Jones - Second round draft choice, above average hit and power tools, .317/.394/.400 slash line, great arm at thrid base, impressed Ryan Vogelsong with his at bats when Vogelsong went on a rehab assignment
15) Eric Surkamp - First year back from Tommy John, above average fastball and curveball, 2.80 ERA and a WHIP of 1.00 across two levels this year, someone to watch compete for a rotation spot come spring training
16) Brian Ragira - Advanced bat out of Stanford, plus hit tool with above average power, needs to cut down on the strikeouts, could advance quickly if he makes adjustments
17) Gary Brown - Plus athlete, excellent make up, plus-plus speed, destroys left-handed pitching, once a considered a cornerstone now his future is in question
18) Francisco Paguero - Good athlete with injury history, above average power and hit tool, also has an incredible arm that profiles well in rightfield
19) Ty Blach - Features an above average fastball and curveball, ERA of 2.90, WHIP of 1.09
20) Daniel Slania - Fifth round pick out of Notre Dame, closer make up, 9.22 K/9, 1.98 BB/9, 1.17 WHIP
Here they are, the future of the San Francisco Giants. The strength of the Giants' system is pitching at the lower levels of the system. Most of pitchers will, next year, begin their ascent to advanced competition as they head up to double and triple - A. The glaring weakness of the Giants system is the hitting. They lack few advanced bats, as well as raw, unrefined hitters; even those who are "advanced" have struggled this year and last in Panik, Brown, and Paguero.
In terms of pitching, keep an eye on the next wave of arms coming up through the system in Crick, Blackburn, Stratton, and Agosta.
In terms of bats, look for Panik to make some adjustments coming into spring training, as he is one of the few advanced, major league ready hitters the Giants have. I am excited about Susac who really made strides this year before getting hurt; if he can cut down on the strikeouts moving forward he will create an interesting dynamic behind home plate. The same idea applies to Mac Williamson, who, if he can cut down on the strikeouts, can be an effective major league hitter. Young hitters like Gustavo Cabrera and Christian Arroyo are flashing impressive skills, but are still a few seasons away and need to refine their overall game.
Stats courtesy of mlb.com, milb.com, and fangraphs.com
Eric, Your #10 prospect, Outfielder Gustavo Cabrera, has apparently suffered a very serious wrist injury! News reports say it was severe enough to almost sever his hand!! However, the reports also say that he should recuperate enough to play next year... does that sound plausible? How does this terrible injury impact his career and the Giants farm system? Where do the Giants go from here? BigDude
ReplyDeleteCabrera's injury was both grotesque and sever and it legitimately jeopardizes his 2014 season. As a very young athlete with very raw tools every year is crucial to their development, therefore this year will be greatly missed. Reports indicate that he will make a full recovery, and he is young enough for that to be plausible. The concern, aside from the physical, is how will he respond to a slow and rigorous rehabilitation process and will be able to play free of concern once he makes it back onto the field. Giants fans will miss him as he is one of the few impact type bats in the system and a hopeful part of their future plans. Also interesting to note is that both of the Giants' international signings will miss significant time next season: Cabrera with his gruesome injury and Nathanael Javier with his suspension for steroid use. Both of these serve as another gloomy reminder that no prospect is "can't miss" and there are always unforeseen obstacles.
Delete