Last week we focused on the future Giants who enjoyed breakout seasons: Kyle Crick, Clayton Blackburn, Martin Agosta and Mac Williamson. In this week's post I will examine farmhands who posted lackluster numbers and didn't quite live up to expectations: Joe Panik, Gary Brown, and Heath Hembree. These three Giants have received a serious amount of acclaim since being drafted, largely because of their success at the lower levels, but enjoyed less success this year than what was expected.
Joe Panik was the first round draft choice of the Giants in the 2011 draft (29 overall) out of St. John's University. Enjoying a great amount of success in his first professional season: being named the MVP of the Northwest League, to the Arizona Fall League Rising Stars game, and an organizational all star. In 2012 he played a full season at high-A San Jose, and although he struggled the first half, finished strong posting a .297 batting average, and walking more times than he struck out (58 vs. 54, respectively). Panik did struggle this year at double-A Richmond with his batting average dipping to .257 - although posting a similar strikeout-to-walk ratio. Panik's defense at short or second has never been stellar, but given the Giants uncertain second base situation, compared to their solidified short stop situation, it was assumed that Panik would slide into the second base slot. Many Giants fans hoped that, given Marco Scutaro's ailing defense, Panik would be ready sooner rather than later. Given that the jump from single-A to double-A is one of the most challenging jumps a prospect will face, and that Richmond is largely a pitcher's park, it is understandable that Panik struggled this year, but a bit disconcerting that he may not be the prospect that Giants's fans hoped he would be. What does bode well for Panik is that he has a solid approach, consistently walking more than he strikes out and consistently putting the ball in play. If Panik can make some adjustments going into spring training he could break with the big league club, but if not, he may need another year at triple-A.
Gary Brown was the first round pick by the Giants in 2010 where he, like Panik, enjoyed considerable success early on. Best know for his speed-hit combination, he was lauded as the center fielder of the future for the Giants. In his first full season at high-A San Jose, Brown his .336 with 14 home runs and 53 stolen bases and showered with accolades (futures game selection, California League Rookie of the Year, Cal League post season all star, Baseball America minor league all star, and MLB.com Class A Advanced hitter of the year). Brown's success tapered off a bit in 2012 at double-A when he hit .279 with 33 stolen bases and an OBP of .347. This year Brown struggled the most, posting a .231 average, 17 stolen bases and an OBP of .286. Brown has dealt with lofty expectations since he was drafted and he has handled these expectations with poise because of his off the charts character and work ethic. He was lauded, coming out of college as one of the best athletes - albeit very raw athletes - available in the 2010 draft, and consistently earns high marks for his athleticism and defense within the Giants organization; but his bat is the concern. Never one to draw high walk totals (46 in 2011 was his highest), his OBP relies heavily on how much contact he makes which is generally not an ideal trait in a prototypical lead off hitter. His strike-out totals are often too high but they are erratic as well, ranging anywhere from 12-22%, which points to an adjustment in approach. Given that Brown's speed is his greatest, and most valuable asset, he has never been efficient on the base paths, getting thrown out 36%, 55%, and 65% of his attempts in 2011, 2012, and 2013, respectively. His unorthodox setup at the plate also hinders him against right handed pitchers because of the way he sets and loads his hands. His age makes it difficult from him to continue to develop, considering also that he has already played a full season of triple-A; Angel Pagan's success at the top of the lineup on the 2012 championship team also complicates matters. I am a fan of Gary Brown and would like to see him succeed with the Giants, however, I do not see him contributing to the big league team in a substantial manner.
Heath Hembree has been hailed as the successor to the closer role in San Francisco. When Brian Wilson went down, fans clamored for his promotion. However Sergio Romo has inherited the closer role and enjoyed more ninth inning success than many fans projected and given Hembree more, much needed, development time. Hembree touts a mid to high 90's fastball and a slider that can be plus with more refinement. His huge season in 2011 really put him on the radar of Giants fans and the front office when he notched 38 saves across two levels. He has struggled in Fresno letting his ERA balloon to 4.07, while maintaining 10.25 K/9 rate and a 3.94 BB/9 rate. Through dealing with injuries he did deal with a dip in velocity and an increase in his walks. Scouts have been impressed with his stint in the big leagues so far (3 IP, 2 BB's, and 3 K's) because he has focused primarily on throwing strikes instead of trying to blow fastballs by major league hitters. Brian Sabean does believe in the development and maturation of future closers from within the system. Hembree should receive sporadic innings depending on game situations throughout the rest of this season. Although his performance this year has been less than stellar, he remains a future closer option down the road. By refining his command and his slider in the off season he is still poised to break with the club and earn regular innings next year.
Facts and statistics courtesy of mlb.com, milb.com and fangraphs.com
No comments:
Post a Comment