My goal for the next few posts is to take a look at how some of the Giants' home-grown talent has progressed from questionably selected draft picks into all-star talent, a look at the Giants' draft selections from the 2014 and 2015, and any other topics that may come along. As usual, if there is anything of particular interest that people would like to discuss, please feel free to comment or respond to these posts.
The trio I'll focus on will be Matt Duffy, Joe Panik, and Brandon Crawford. Together these young infielders have formed the foundation of the Giants' sustainable future. Although they do not have the flash of many of the young players crashing upon the shores of baseball in this unparalleled talent wave, they nevertheless represent shrewd, creative, and successful drafting practices that have allowed the Giants to win three of the last five world series.
I'll start with Matt Duffy. Drafted as an 18th round pick out of California State University at Long Beach he was unheralded as the 568th overall selection. On the surface he possessed little more than fringe-average tools across the board and he didn't have the prolific college career we, as fans, typically associate with MLB draft picks. Here are his collegiate statistics taken from McCovey Chronicles:
2010 (freshman year): .244/.245/.291, 0 HR
2011: .266/.298/.290, 0 HR
2012: .244/.336/.289, 0 HR
However, these numbers are a bit misleading. Coming off his sophomore year he went to the prestigious Cape Cod league where he finished third in the circuit with a .348 batting average after making small, but effective adjustments regarding how far back he stood from the plate. Moving back a bit helped him avoid getting jammed and allowed him to extend his arms and see the pitch longer. His growth as a hitter was soon stunted as a stomach aliment plagued him and cost him 10 pounds he could ill afford to lose. All of this played into the Giants' fortunate selection.
A preliminary analysis of Duffy's minor league numbers present an intriguing prospect. Standard statistical evaluations would display a steady producer, but little more than a system player or versatile utility man. In two years he played across four levels, played in 248 games and came to bat 1087 times. In this time he hit 13 home runs, stole a respectable 55 bags, posted a solid 1.21:1 strikeout-to-walk ratio, and an impressive .304/.387/.413 triple slash line.
However, a more thorough statistical analysis presents a consistently above average hitter who did many things well. Despite never hitting for much power in his minor league career, he consistently posted OPS's that fell in the "above average" category (as determined by fangraphs) .647, .832, .823, .852, and .842 at A-, A, A+, and AAA, respectively. His minor league career OPS stands at .791.
I few figures I'll point out that might have indicated Duffy's future success:
I few figures I'll point out that might have indicated Duffy's future success:
wRC+ (weighted runs created): Per fangraphs, "a statistic which attempts to credit a hitter for the value of each outcome rather than treating all hits or times on base equally, while also controlling for park effects..." Furthermore, it attempts to measure each player against an average of 100. Every point above or below 100 corresponds to 1 or 2 percent above or below average. Duffy's minor league wRC+ stands at an impressive 123.8 (23.8% above average). By minimizing his strikeouts, maximizing his contact and walk rates, and running the bases well he's turned himself into a solid regular at the major league level.
While fangraphs doesn't have stratified ranking designations for BABIP or slugging percentage, "average", "above average", etc, they do provide league averages. MLB average for BABIP and slugging are .298 and .398, respectively. Duffy currently stands at .356 and .465. Both of these figures are significantly above average and in line with his minor league numbers (career .329 BABIP and .414 slugging). Duffy's career numbers also fall significantly above league averages and at this point we get a pretty good idea as to what made him successful. He doesn't strike out excessively, consistently puts the pall in play, pounds the gaps for extra bases, and can run the bases effectively.
While fangraphs doesn't have stratified ranking designations for BABIP or slugging percentage, "average", "above average", etc, they do provide league averages. MLB average for BABIP and slugging are .298 and .398, respectively. Duffy currently stands at .356 and .465. Both of these figures are significantly above average and in line with his minor league numbers (career .329 BABIP and .414 slugging). Duffy's career numbers also fall significantly above league averages and at this point we get a pretty good idea as to what made him successful. He doesn't strike out excessively, consistently puts the pall in play, pounds the gaps for extra bases, and can run the bases effectively.
Not long ago Duffy would have been branded as someone who couldn't fit the third base prototype. While front office executives still look for power production out of their third basemen, we are seeing more players come up in the mold of Duffy. For every Todd Frazier, Josh Donaldson, or Manny Machado, there's a Jung Ho Kang, Justin Turner or Matt Carpenter. Guys who have the ability to be productive big leaguers by getting on base and putting the ball and play.
Duffy could have been selected by 29 other teams and 567 picks earlier. However, the Giants' scouting staff found the needle in the hay stack and what they have is a rookie third basemen playing at a rookie of the year level.
Stay tuned for more articles detailing home grown talent and go Giants!
Great blog Eric! Love to see your enthusiasm for your hometown team! Go Giants!!!
ReplyDelete